Love and Hate
She came out on the balcony to see the rainbow: with all its
colours, on the eastern sky, like a bridge, bridging the north with the
south. Shining. Evanescent. Colourful. The colours fading into one
another producing hues and shades on the dull blue canvas. And far away
she knew it was raining for she could see the dark clouds hovering in
the distance. It must be still raining there, she thought. Pouring,
showering, drenching; birds, trees, trains. Spurting from the dust,
jutting from the railings, splashing on the sides, submerging the
tracks and ... She knew; she felt. She wondered why rainbows are not of
any other shape. Why are they shaped like bridges? She thought she
knew why. Because they bridge north with the south. She smiled. She
wanted to laugh; laugh loudly so that the innumerable pairs of ears
beyond the great arch might hear her. But she knew she can’t. So she
smiled in ecstasy. Seeing her smile the children came out of the folds
of her sari with their faces still in a conundrum. They began to stare
at the beautiful spectacle. A bridge from north to south. And he was
coming from the north.
Presently the little girl gave a shout, VIBGYOR. And her
brother started saying aloud Violet, Indigo, Blue, Green, Yellow,
Orange, Red. red, red, red, red, the red colour seem to echo in the
mother’s ears. She felt it was a strange colour; most unlike any other
colour. It was a living colour as well as a deadly colour. The colour of
life as well as death. And she knew it was the colour of the setting
sun. Today also, like any other day, she won’t see the sun at dusk. In
this flat in the ghetto the western side never had a horizon. It only
has neighbours. So for ten years she didn’t see the sun set. It wasn’t
the sun did not set all these years but for her the sun only rose.
Sometimes in the rain.
But the children were still more unfortunate. When she was in
the north, everyday she saw the sun set. Sometimes in the rain. But
alas! The children had never seen the setting sun. The only time they
saw a tinge of red in the sky was when there was a rainbow. So they
began to love the rainbow dearly. Whenever there was a rainbow they used
to rush to look at it with puzzled expressions on their faces. They
waited for the rainbow. Days on end. Sometimes on bright, sunny days
they used to rush to the balcony and stare at the sky and ask, will we
get a rainbow today mom? And the mother used to answer, if it rains. So
they began to love the rains too. But the rains were a bugger. It
betrayed the children. It hurt the children. Now and again; for not all
rainy days the rainbow came out. The mother grew worried when it
rained and rained for days and days without the rainbow. And always,
before the internecine rains could cause any harm, the rainbow came out.
The children were joyous; the mother was happy; the rainbow becalmed
all their sufferings, pain and anxiety for the time being. The rainbow
was so beautiful, so colourful. The red colour contrasting with the
blue of the sky. But the mother knew that their happiness was as
fleeting as the rainbow. So gradually, unknowingly she became afraid of
the rains. Whether it drizzled, showered or poured her heart sank
heavily in her bosom. And the children seeing the mixed expression of
love and hate on her face had their faces riddled with confusion. They
knew not that their mother feared the rains, except when it rained at
night and when it rained with a rainbow.
The mother and the children stared at the rainbow until it
grew dark and the rainbow faded into the azure. Then she ushered her
children into the room from the balcony. They had today’s fill. She
hoped they will remain glad all through their maternal uncle’s visit.
She prayed again that anxiety might not overcome their gaiety in the
coming days. The coming days were important for her. She had waited for
it for ten long years. For ten long years everyday she waited for
these days and now when these days were so close she grew nervous. It
seemed that these days have come too early. It could have waited a
little longer. She could have prepared herself. Prepared her home.
Prepared what she had been preparing these ten long years. Still after
ten years of restlessness she wants a little more time. Till her
husband gets a good promotion or till they get into a good house or till
they own a lot of things they had planned to own or till her children
are grown up and established or ... But now the days were there. The
days after which she was running so long that now she can’t run away
from them.
She went to the kitchen to prepare food for the man of the
house. The ushered-in children sat on the bed with their books and
copies to do their homework. The father will be home soon.
It was not long when the doorbell rang and entered a surly, burly
figure. A figure whom the children had got accustomed to looking at
this hour of the day. The man sat where he was accustomed to sit. Very
soon his tea will arrive which he will slurp happily. The children
feigned to be busy with their homework. They loved their father dearly
but they also knew that their father so nonchalant towards them that it
was akin to hatred. So they need not and should not disturb him.
After some time the tea arrived with their mother. They saw
everything with their heads in their books and copies and their eyes
slanting away. The father sipping tea. The mother standing with the
tray in hand and watching the man of the house with contempt. When is he
coming? the man asked earnestly. The train is due to arrive at eight,
she answered blankly.
But it is surely to be late by an hour or so.
Yes.
Is the room okay? I mean have you cleared all their things and
locked the cupboards, he asked staring at the children from his cup.
Yes; again was her short reply.
And, and the new bed-sheet.
Yes.
He must feel comfortable. You must look to it. He is coming
after such a long time. He must not feel any discomfort while staying
here. He is our guest. And the children must also behave well.
Yes.
She went to the kitchen with the empty cup and saucer. He got
up and went to the basin to wash himself. He came back with a towel on
his shoulder and reseated himself on his chair. The wife hated him
because of, among other things, this habit of not himself before taking
tea. But the children loved him all because of his bad habits. After
taking the hot tea he seemed to cool down a bit because of the wash.
And that was the time the children thought when he became a little
indulgent with them and their work.
The boy seizing the opportunity jumped down from the bed and came
beside his father. He asked him to explain a problem in arithmetic. The
father obliged and explained it to him as if he was lecturing a class
of hundred students. The boy shook his head even though he could not
make out anything of the explanation. But it wasn’t that he did not
understand the problem for he had already solved it; it was just to talk
to his father. When he returned from his endeavour the younger one
jumped down from the bed with a book in hand. She opened the book on a
certain page and gave it to her father. Then she began to recite from
memory the poem. The father stopped the recitation mid-way and said,
Darling ask your brother. He’ll hear it. She returned to the bed with
her book. That was probably the end of their conversation with their
father for the day. They went on doing their work either in pretence or
in reality. Laboriously. While the father lighted a cigarette and
began to go through the morning newspaper. It was quite warm outside
but the children could feel their insides getting colder and colder.
The children would then start shivering momentarily in periodic
intervals, sometimes long and sometimes short. And each time they
shivered the children used to turn their faces hither and thither like
fawns and make sure that no one noticed them. Then they would stare at
each other and wait for another round of fits to come. This went on and
time passed. After eight O’ clock they had their day’s last meal. By
nine they were in bed and by ten they were fast asleep. Still there was
no sign of their uncle. Meanwhile the train from north Bengal, the
Darjeeling Express, was three and a half hour late. So when it reached
Howrah it was almost half past eleven. From the first class compartment
stepped down, among others, a man in traditional Bengali dress. He
called a coolie. The coolie took his suitcase outside the station and
arranged a cab for him. The driver seeing a well-dressed Bengali
“bhadrolok” asked to be paid fifty rupees extra. When the coolie
assured him that the driver was charging reasonably he yielded. It was
well towards midnight when his taxi was going smoothly over the
Vidyasagar Setu that his thoughts veered again and again towards his
sister. He began to think of her ten years ago. How they used to run
down the declivity of their tea garden. How they used to play
hide-and-seek among the bushy trees. How they used to wait for the
snowfall. How they used to run after the toy trains. How they used to
see the sun rising from the Tiger Hill. And how they used to see the
sun set in the western horizon with a red glare. And before she realised
that he was old enough to fall in love and run away with the
no-Bengali tea estate manager of their firm, she was gone. He never
forgave her for that. These thoughts began to make inroads into his
mind. He wanted to just stare at the road, slipping past the tyres of
the cab but hat also tormented him. He felt that as the car sped he was
getting nearer and nearer, faster and faster to something unpleasant.
It was getting unbearable. He began to hate his sister more and more.
His pleasure trip was becoming from unpleasureable to displeasureable.
He wanted to turn back. And he decides that he won’t stay for more than
a day in his sister’s house. So when he knocked on the door quite past
midnight and his sister opened the door the first thing he said was, I
paid rupees fifty extra for the taxi.
The night was slumbering. so they all went to sleep. Some minds were
occupied in thoughts and some in dreams. But outside the wind wasn’t
slumbering, the moon wasn’t slumbering, the stars weren’t slumbering.
The earth was awake that night. Had anyone of them opened their sleepy
eyes that night they would have realised that they were the only ones
sleeping that night. And dreaming. Outside there was a conspiracy. In
their bed chamber air was filling in thick. Until it was so dense that
it felt like liquid. So they all opened their mouth and gulped in
mouthfuls. The air going in their lungs like thick treacle. It seemed
that they would suffocate and die but they lived. Lived through the
night as if they knew about it all. As if they have been prepared.
Preparing themselves for ten years. Ten long years. Even the children
were aware. It seemed.
So they all slumbered unaware of the ticking clock until the
wind which has raved all night restlessly, sleeplessly banged a window
pane and the house was awake. All were awake, at once. The children got
up and stared at each other fearing another bout of fits. The father
and the mother beside them woke up in love and hate. And in that other
room the uncle who arrived last night was also awaken by the noise.
Suddenly they were all awake and all aware that they were all awake. It
seemed the day dawned suddenly without the twilight. It seemed the
other moment it was night and the very next moment it was day.
Suddenly.
The children already knew that the uncle must have arrived but
still while brushing their teeth they asked their mother, Has uncle
arrived, mom? Was the train late? Why didn’t you wake us up? At what
time did he come? How long will he stay? Is he very rich? Was he happy?
And the mother replied sometimes with certainty and sometimes
doubtfully; sometimes with a yes and sometimes with a no; sometimes she
advised them and sometimes she kept quite; sometimes she nodded her
head and sometimes she shook her head.
It was not long when they met their uncle. He was most unlike
the young man they had expected to see. He was no more the same youth
whose picture they had seen in their mother’s family photograph. The
boyish cheerfulness of his face was gone; instead a grave expression
was on his face. Now he can only be cheerful when he wishes to be so.
They could not read his face clearly. Was he a friend or foe? They could
not make out. So they put aside all their conjectures. They were ready
to let time and actions guide their feelings.
The uncle, on first impression appeared cheerful with them. He
addressed them by their first names. He caressed them with genuine
warmth. He behaved with them as if he was meeting with them after a
long time and not exactly for the first time. But the children found
that their uncle was quite cold with their mother. He was warm with
their father, so why coldness with the only other remaining member of
their family? They reserved their opinion about him for the time being.
They won’t haste. They wanted to know what ten years’ separation from
his sister has cooked in his heart and mind. Was it love or hate? Ten
years is a long time and anything that has been cooked in his heart and
mind for all those time is sure to decide the future, far away. Now
they just waited for the immediate future.
At breakfast their uncle was most animated. His
tintinabulating voice aroused their awe. He talked about anything under
the sun. He talked with their father jovially, cheerily and sometimes
seriously. He amused them with his knowledge, with his etiquette, with
his mannerisms, with his facial acrobatics, with his gung-ho spirit.
But the children felt a pin-prick in all their amusements. They saw
their mother; her face expressing the pain of torture. She was
uncomfortable; she was bottled up; she was suffocating. It seemed that
all night she had just breathed in and not breathed out. They pitied
their mother But they knew not why she was in such a poor state when
others were enjoying themselves.
After breakfast the mother went into the kitchen for she had much
work to do. She was happy to be away. The children were happy that
alone in the kitchen she might feel a little better. The father would
stay in that dining-room-cum-drawing-room. With their uncle. And
possibly the children would also stay there. It was a Sunday. So the
four of them sat in the room and conversed. Every word of their
conversation was distinctly heard in the kitchen. And the mother was
aware that the father would try his best to send the children away from
his sight. He could not tolerate them. But the uncle wanted them in
there. She was glad for that. All through the day, till the afternoon,
the struggle of the farther would continue. And neither the children
nor the uncle would know the strife going on. The mother would know.
She would loathe her husband for that. Soon she found the children
running into the bedroom, now to get the newspaper, now to get their
father’s spectacles, and now for something else. They always ran for
their errands at a single command from their father. They loved their
father. How can they disobey him? They ran in pairs. Never separating
from each other. They were like Siamese twins. They were so close to
each other. They shared something common between themselves - if not
physically an organ or something then certainly something
psychological. Either they had a common id or a common ego or they might
have a common super-ego. There wasn’t anything to show that one of
them was dominant over the other. They were both, as if, finely tuned
to play the same note. The mother saw it and liked it. She was also
once so close to her brother. The father also saw it but did not like
it. He felt their closeness too sticky. But what can he do? So he
remained indifferent towards them. And his wife did not approve of his
attitude. So the children ran here and there pleasing their father. The
mother getting annoyed every time they were on the run. But every time
they returned from their errand their uncle had new things to tell them
about. They were eager to hear. Hear how their mother spent her
childhood with her brother.
The uncle said, We used to run down the declivity of the
tea-garden and there used to be those bushes behind which we used to
hide while playing hide-and-seek.
The father ordered them to go and confirm whether it was true
or not. They rushed to their mother. Is it true, mom, is it true? The
mother answered, yes, in agony. And then.
We used to wait for the snow fall so longingly and sometimes in
the snow we used to run after the toy train and always beating it in
our run.
Again they were rushed to the kitchen for confirmation. And
each time they met the eyes of their mother they found her in extreme
agony. Gradually they were figuring out the ploy. And then.
We used to see the sun rising from the Tiger Hill. Oh! What a sight
it is! And again it agonised the mother. She prayed to god that the
father won’t send the children again to her to increase her agony. But
she knew he would. He was as stupid, senseless and stubborn as a
dotard. Why had she married him? Infatuation, and nothing else. What
else can it be? She was enamoured by his masculinity. His soul had
forever remained a far country for her. Unapproached. Unexamined.
Unexplored. He was now just a big dildo for her. She realised that back
then her heart did not reason. But it was not so now. All was changed.
She no longer loved him. She could not love him. Since she could not
love him, she hated him. And again.
We used to see the sun set with its red glare.
They went to the mother and asked, Did you see the sun set
with a red glare? And this they saw that their mother’s eyes were red.
They knew she was repressing something. It might be tears. Yes. Tears.
It seemed that just then it was going to burst out in rains. Drizzling.
Showering. Pouring. The mother got afraid. She turned aside. She won’t
speak. For fear. With the pointed end of the kitchen knife she carved
on the table YES. The children saw and knew. They knew it was their
uncle who was making their mother suffer. Consciously. They began to
hate him. Hate him to the core. They realised that everything he said
was directed at their mother. To tease her. To make her suffer.
Reminiscences which will wound her. Their uncle was sinister. He hated
their mother and they hated him.
The lunch was a light affair. There was no tension, struggle
or strife nor was the air as thick as liquid. It was because all of
them were of anything but eating. The father was tired of ordering, the
uncle was tired of recalling the past, the mother was tired of hearing
about her past and the children were tired of running for errands. But
they were all aware; all five of them, that what they had been doing so
long in the hiding, they will have to do it in direct confrontation.
After lunch when they would all be together and resting, the tension
would be at its height. And it might not last long before...
They were all bound together by love. But their love for each
other was like lassoes and lariats - the noose of which was hate. If
they loved too much the noose might get tighter round the throat. They
all knew, even the little ones, that love has a potency to give birth
but hate has a greater potency to cause death.
Immediately after lunch the uncle took out a photograph from his
suitcase and also opened the floodgates of confrontation. It was an
old, black and white, sepia-tint photograph. It showed a tall monument
beneath which stood a boy and a girl, arm in arm. The boy and girl were
not much older than the brother and sister we know about as children.
The boy and girl were also brother and sister. A more than ten years old
photograph. The uncle showed it to the children. Even before they
recognised the tall monument as the Shahid Minar, they recognised that
the boy and girl were their uncle and mother respectively. Standing
below the towering architecture. Smiling. At the camera. And now at
them. Show it to your mother, the uncle said. But the children would
not yield to his ploy any more. They refused. The father was angry. The
uncle himself handed the photograph to their mother. She did not want
to take it. He forced her. She took it and folded her arms. He won’t
take it back from her until the photograph has done its work. She was to
suffer, he decided. The children’s eyes were full of hate for their
uncle. And the father in turn began to them even more. And the mother’s
hate grew more for her husband when she found how, along with her, her
children also suffered.
It was a whirlpool. A vortex of love and hate. Everyone knew that
they were sinking. All. Still they were trying to hold on to others
either in their last ditch attempt to get refuge or to make sure that
along with them the others also sink. It was both a struggle against
each other and a struggle against struggle. A situation where salvation
was annihilation and annihilation was salvation. They had all painted
themselves into a single corner. Whose mistake was it?
They all knew. They all knew enough. They all knew enough to know that they did not know.
The uncle spoke, That’s the Octolorney Monument. And that’s me and your mother. What do you about the monument?
It’s now called the Shahid Minar, replied the little ones.
And what else?
They kept quiet. They knew no more. The father was piqued, even
though he knew nothing more about it. He shouted, Idiots.
The uncle intervened in the crisis. But the mother spoke first,
Don’t ever you speak like that to my children. Behaving as if you know
a lot.
Then the uncle, just to make his sister worse, reproduced the
exact words that they had heard just after they had got themselves
photographed under the monument, on their first visit to Calcutta.
The guide spoke, It is sometimes called “Kolkata ka debota”
(The presiding deity of Calcutta). It has a very peculiar architectural
style. Its base is modelled in Egyptian style. Its column is Syrian.
And its dome is made in Turkish style.
The children and their father heard these facts for the first
time. The children hated their uncle still more for showing off his
vast oeuvre of knowledge. They made faces at him. The father was
impressed by the uncle. And he hated the children for hating their
uncle. Only the mother knew about these facts. The familiar words wrung
her being. It seemed that someone was thrusting his hand in her chest
and pulling out her heart. How happy she was in those days. In her
childhood. Until. She threw down the photograph on the bed. The father
winced. The children knew that their uncle was destroying their mother.
At present in their family the uncle was like a fifth quarter - an
intruder. An impostor. An unwanted guest. The mother wished that her
brother would forgive her. She loved her brother dearly. But she knew
not that while all these years she was storing up love for her brother,
her brother was storing up hate for her. He was adamant to remain an
intruder. An impostor. An unwanted guest.
The children wanted to know more about one thing that fascinated
them. The setting of the sun with a red glare. But they feared that it
would hurt their mother. So they kept quiet. They weren’t surprised
when, despite their fears, the subject was taken up by none other than
their uncle. They looked at their mother. She was prepared. They were a
little relieved.
How often do you’ll see the setting sun? The setting of the
sun with a red glare. Just as we used to see in those days, asked the
uncle.
Often, retorted the husband.
Never, countered the wife.
Why, rejoined the uncle.
You know, dear. Now don’t punish me. Have pity on me, moaned the sister.
I am sorry if I have caused you any pain. But I am not. I just
wanted to recall those days of our childhood. I didn’t mean to.
No, you do it purposefully. You bother our mother, cried two voices in unison.
Suddenly the father towered over them and just managed to control himself from hitting them.
Is that the way to talk to your elders? Don’t you have any manners? You brutes.
Shut-up, shut-up. Don’t try to show your over-smartness, my dear husband, hollered the wife.
When the sun sets, continued the uncle, the sky and the sun
both are so red. It seems that somebody has spilled on the western
horizon. It’s the only time the sky and the sun seem to have a blood
relationship. Just as we used to have.
“Used to have.” The words registered in the mind it was
intended for. The whole atmosphere was now so tense that it looked like
a stretched balloon. Even a slight pin-prick would cause large gaping
holes in it. But their world was in a well and who would go in the well
with a pin. The liquid air that they were all breathing for so long,
laboriously, now was in such a state that they all knew that any moment
it might solidify and they would all die of suffocation. For want of
air. If they all have top die then why does death not come at once? Why
was the delay? How long are they to wait? They could not stand the
tension building up. But their fate was linked with the colour red. Red
is both the colour of life and of death. So they have to live and die
at the same time. They would live to die and die to live. A state of
uncertainty. A state of delirium. Not induced by any drug, but by their
intricate love-hate relationship. They would stay in a state of
indecision, for they have loved and hated at the same time. They would
be stoned for life ... unless ... until...
They kept quiet. No one spoke. Time passed as if in slow motion.
Still they did not speak. They knew to speak is but to cough out blood
from their mouth. That was agony. It had a red colour. The colour of
life. The colour of death. The colour of the setting sun. And the only
colour of the rainbow that contrasts with the azure the most. So they
kept quiet. They were afraid to meet each other’s eyes. So they stared
away. Mainly at the sky. Some saw a bright sun beaming in the sky. Some
saw dark clouds hovering in the sky. Some saw a rainbow in the sky.
Some saw it was raining. And some saw it was raining with a rainbow.
Everyone saw a separate thing. They didn’t divulge what they saw to
each other. They would keep it a secret. In the secret chamber of their
heart. Time passed ever so slowly. Still they were silent. Until it
chimed and it was almost time.
I am almost late. I have only an hour and a half’s time, declared the uncle.
Suddenly the stretched band of tension that was engulfing them
began to get perforated at a number of places. Fresh air gushed in.
They were at last to breathe freely. Their lungs were in a poor state.
So was their heart. How much blood was in it? How red was the blood?
Will anyone fever spill their blood in the skies of the western horizon?
Will their rainbows ever have the red colour? They were busy.
Tea was prepared and served. Everyone was again happy. But no
one knew that others were also happy, so they did not show their joy.
Instead they remained thoughtful and brooding. It was not more than
half an hour before they realised that though their lives were
proceeding they were not proceeding towards the future. The past was
ahead of them. Again they will fall into a ten year long wait. Again
they will busy themselves preparing for a future day. A day like this
that might not come again after a ten year gap. It might take longer.
They wanted time to take its own sweet time. They won’t hurry time
anymore. They won’t wait for someone to come from the north. They would
wait instead for the rains. Or the rainbow. So what if the rains were a
bugger. Nature is not as harmful as others are. Nature is
compassionate. It will oblige before any harm is done. It might be they
won’t see the sun setting with a red glare for ten more years or for
twenty more years or even more. They would be satisfied and happy and
pleased to see the red colour in the sky only when there is a rainbow.
It will bring them happiness. The little tensions in their family will
be like some slow poison administered in very small doses. They would
all be aware of it. But they would also know that they are not going to
die. They will live. Nature will protect them. They will live for ten
years or for twenty years or more till their uncle returns. Of course
the rainbow will still form a bridge. Bridging the north with the
south. And the hope won’t die that since the bridge is there the
distance will be bridged one day.
He left when it was quite dark. Again he will have to pay fifty
rupees extra to the taxi. Again the coolie will say that it is
reasonable. Again he will sit in the first class compartment. Again the
train will trudge up north. And if it rains then ... spurting from the
dust, jutting from the railings, splashing on the sides, submerging the
tracks... and...
The children woke up early the next morning. It was a bright
sunny day. They rushed to the balcony and stared at the sky. Their
mother also came. They hid themselves in the folds of her sari. They
asked, Will we get a rainbow today, mom? The father, who was nearby,
wanted to answer either yes or no, But the mother replied, If it rains.